The Alan Katz Health Care Reform Blog

Health Care Reform From One Person's Perspective

Governor’s Health Care Site Misses the Point

Posted by Alan on October 19, 2007

OK. We all know that when politicians and political parties take surveys on their web sites or through direct mail they really aren’t doing sophisticated research. They ask leading questions of the “do you support laws which make your life better or do you want laws that will make your life a living hell” variety. There’s no reason we should hold Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to a higher standard, but there’s something about this example that ticked me off. And hey, it’s my blog, so ….

Rumor had it the Governor was going to formally respond to the unions today so I was checking out his official web site ( for those of you playing along at home). I then clicked on the “HEALTHCARE” link in the bottom left of the page, which takes one to the Administration’s health care reform site ( Scrolling down a bit I came to the Governor’s “Quick Poll.” Since it may not be there for long (hopefully), here is what I saw:

Most Responsible for Increasing Health Care Costs:

  • Employers not offering workers insurance
  • Too many uninsured people costing taxpayers money
  • Insurance that is expensive and hard to get
  • Out-of-pocket expenses that are high
  • Medications are costly

Isn’t there something missing here? OK, isn’t there a whole lot missing here? Why is there no mention about what everyone knows is really driving increased health care costs and health insurance premiums? Things like an aging population, new technologies, and increased consumer expectations concerning what the health care system should deliver? A choice of “Medications are costly” heads in that direction, but doesn’t get anywhere near to this point. 

Gee, Governor Schwarzenegger, maybe the reason employers don’t offer workers insurance, too many people are uninsured, insurance is too expensive and out-of-pocket expenses are high is that the cost of health care is rising far faster than wages or general inflation? Health care is so expensive that when the government pays the bill (think MediCal) they refuse to pay the going rate. Which means hospitals and doctors need to increase what they charge those with private insurance to make up the difference. Now that’s a hidden tax and my guess is it outweighs the cost of uncompensated care.

The Administration knows this. So why offer a survey that is insulting, misleading and a waste of Internet bandwidth?

The answer is: because they can. And it’s what happens when politics trumps policy. The Governor himself probably never saw this poll — and certainly won’t be seeing the results of it. Whichever staff person added it should very quickly and quietly remove it. A blank space on the web site would be an improvement.

Is this making a big deal out of something inconsequential? Yep. But hey, I feel better now.

5 Responses to “Governor’s Health Care Site Misses the Point”

  1. Matt said


    Can you please put a link so I can see these studies. I find that hard to believe. People that dont pay taxes are adding to the pool? People that get paid under the table are adding to the pool? I find that so hard to believe and I would love to see a study showing that. Also, I live in California where it is a little different then the rest of the country. MEXICO IS RIGHT BELOW US. Many of the workers send the money to their families back home, in which case the money isnt even going into our economy. And Alan, are you Alan Katz or just another Alan? If this Alan Katz, then I should just stop now. Either way, let me know. I would be more than happy to admit I am wrong. SHOW ME A LINK.

  2. Alan said

    Matt: Some people may think illegal immigrants are responsible for the high cost of health care but they’d be wrong. Every study I’ve come across indicates that undocumented workers as a whole are a net plus for the economy, generating taxes and increasing productivity. They add plenty of water to the pool.

  3. Oh yea……..if the government doesn’t pay the going rate, why should we?

    Is the government responsible for the high cost of healthcare?

    Are illegal immigrants responsible?

    I know some people in California might think so.

    Illegal immigrants drink from the pool but don’t add water so the next person can drink. Weird analogy but I think it proves a point. Don’t take what’s not yours and as long as people do that, the responsible ones will continue to pay higher premiums and suffer.

  4. That poll is a joke. The poll asks what is “Most Responsible for Increasing Health Care Costs”. 42% said “Insurance that is expensive and hard to get”. Everyone knows insurance is expensive and on the individual side very hard to get. The question asked what is “Most Responsible for Increasing Health Care Costs”. Something being expensive isnt the reason its expensive. That poll is a joke and anyone that takes it seriously is being duped.

  5. Meg McComb said

    When has getting the government involved ever saved money?

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

%d bloggers like this: