The Alan Katz Health Care Reform Blog

Health Care Reform From One Person's Perspective

Congressional Health Care Reform Plan Waiting for New President

Posted by Alan on February 27, 2008

During their Ohio debate Tuesday night, Senator Hillary Clinton and Senator Barack Obama spent the opening 16 minutes diving deep into the minutia of their health care reform plans. The public has heard the debate many times before. One might be forgiven for believing the differences actually matter. They don’t.

The reality is that health care reform will be a top priority for either of these candidates should they gain the White House. What plan eventually emerges will be negotiated, compromised and updated so much and so often, it may bear little resemblance to the proposals Senators Clinton and Obama have put on the table. And that’s fine. No one has the secret formula. Crafting the best health care platform for America should involve a great many people not yet heard from.

Then there’s the health care reform proposal already waiting for the new president. Sponsored by Democratic Senator Ron Wyden and Republican Senator Bob Bennett, the Healthy Americans Act is the most bi-partisan and prominent bill stewing in the current Congress — or any recent one, for that matter.  Supported by a dozen senators, six from each party, in many ways it goes much further than the plans being promoted by the Democratic presidential candidates. And compared to Senator John McCain’s market-based reform plan, it’s downright radical.

Twelve percent of the Senate is a long way from a majority. But it’s a start. Even Senators Wyden and Bennett don’t agree with every aspect of their bill. The plan requires all Americans to buy coverage. It does away with the preferential tax treatment of employer-based coverage, forcing individuals to purchase their own coverage through regional purchasing pools. While it’s not a single-payer system, those pools do mean multiple governmental agencies will be running the show.

The Healthy Americans Act is, as it stands, seriously flawed. But that’s not the point. The details of this legislation don’t matter any more than the specifics of the candidate’s proposals. What matters is the existence of a bi-partisan coalition of Senators waiting for a president who is serious about building a consensus to appear on the scene. That’s fertile ground for a serious debate and equally serious negotiations about a complex and vital issue. And that’s good news.


2 Responses to “Congressional Health Care Reform Plan Waiting for New President”

  1. In my work I have found that medically applied massage can eliminate most pain and cure many comman ailments. Safe, natural and great results. In my 24 years of practice and as a reseaacher I have found that there is a science behind this magic and have been working on developing new technology to assess and treat pain, trigger and pressure points. I would love to share my discoveries and have three published abstracts in the Canadian Pain Society jounal on pain. This is the answer we are all looking for but it is hard to pay for the cost of developing this answer let alone once it is built getting it to market. I have been trying to figure out how to get this truth to Obama in time for his Health Care Reform.

  2. leeaase said

    I work for Mayo Clinic, and we are hosting a national symposium on health care reform next week in Leesburg, Va. We’ve also set up a blog so people can watch the streaming video and contribute to the discussions. I hope you and your readers will join us. This blog has links to the Mayo Clinic Health Policy Center for background on our efforts to help create the national consensus the next president will need to enact meaningful, comprehensive reform. I hope you and your readers will check it out.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

%d bloggers like this: